My writing partner, Sara, posted her great film adaptations list yesterday so I thought I’d insert MY favorite films that are great representatives of the novels that came before them.

1. 1995: BBC Pride and Prejudice (With Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle)- First let me say… Because this version is 5 hours long… it’s incredibly like the book!

2. 1994: Little Women (with Susan Sarandon, Winona Ryder and Kirsten Dunst)- I watched this growing up as a child, read the book and they are incredibly similar

3. 1990’s Jane Eyre: I prefer this one to the recent 2011 film because the 90’s film includes the EXTREMELY important gothic elements that the recent film leaves out.

4. The Phantom of the Opera: Ok I understand that this is really a play but the film version of the play released sometime in the early 2000’s is very similar to the book. (This is a rare case where I prefer the movie over the book)

5. Vanity Fair (With Reese Witherspoon): elements were changed but all in all- it plays very similar to the novel

6. Emma: The Kate Beckinsale NOT the Gweneth Paltrow version

7. BBC Northanger Abbey: It’s straight out of the book… LOVE!

8. Sense and Sensibility (Emma Thompson, Hugh Grant and Kate Winslet) need I say more? :)

9. Pretty Much any Nicholas Sparks movie: (The Notebook, A Walk to Remember, The Last Song…) These aren’t my favorite types of movies but I enjoy the books for an easy read and the movies are generally very similar to the novels.

10. I’m sorry… I just have to do it… The 2004 Pride and Prejudice… (w/ Keira Knightly) While it misses characters and minor situations of the novel, it carries the spirit and idea of the novel perfectly… plus- I am much more likely to sit down and watch this versus the 5 hour version.

There are plenty of other films that I ADORE but haven’t read the novels so they didn’t make this list.

Considering writing the next blog on TERRIBLE film adaptations of novels… THOUGHTS?

Latest posts by gliterary girl (see all)

Showing 2 comments
  • Edgar
    Reply

    The world war z adapton that is currently being filmed by brad pitts production company, starring brad pitt.

    • 2 Gliterary Girls
      Reply

      Yeah…that’s been pushed because of major re-shoots. Don’t expect it too to come out anytime soon.

Leave a Comment